Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101
HAYLEY – Weekly Writing for Rhetoric of Gaming F2017

Hayley Project 2 Process Points

  1. Topic Proposal, containing a topic, a working thesis, and at least one primary (game object) and secondary source shared via the weekly blogs, no later than 1159 11/29 (5%) YES
  2. Presentation of topic proposal, in class 11/30 (5 %) YES
  3. Defense of topic proposal  in conference with me no later than 11/29 (5%) YES
  4. An initial draft project in the format it will be submitted (either google docs or web page) linked from the blogs no later than 12/5 (5%) YES
  5. Commenting on two other writing projects via the blogs, on or before 12/8 (5%); YES
  6. A draft conference with me, on or before 12/8, show substantial progress on a drafted project (5%) YES
  7. A near-final draft, shared/linked from a post on our shared blog, on or before 12/13 (5%); YES
  8. A final round of commenting on two drafts, due on or before 12/15 (5%); YES
  9. The quality of the finished project, due on 12/16 (55%) YES

Project 2 Proposal: Hayley, Domenico, Elliott

Topic Proposal: For our project we want to work together to create a game and a website/guide for that game. We are thinking of creating an educational game that promotes an interest in literature to individuals who  enjoy playing video games more than reading books. Our game will use intertextuality to draw upon moments from a specific short story in an attempt to motivate the player and/or teach them important lessons that can be gleaned from the story. Our hope is that we can create a game this is entertaining and educational (NOT boring!).

Primary Source: As I Lay Dying  (the potential story we may draw upon for the game)

The Stanley Parable (game)

Potential Secondary Sources: 

Jolley, Kristie. “Video Games to Reading: Reaching out to Reluctant Readers.” The English Journal, vol. 97, no. 4, 2008, pp. 81–86. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/30047252.

Nicholson, Scott. “Reframing Gaming.” American Libraries, vol. 39, no. 7, 2008, pp. 50–51. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/25650027.

Adams, Megan Glover. “Engaging 21st-Century Adolescents: Video Games in the Reading Classroom.” The English Journal, vol. 98, no. 6, 2009, pp. 56–59. JSTOR.

Rhetorical Analysis #10

Laser Tag is an interactive strategy game that places its players within a video game-like environment. It’s dark, there are black lights everywhere and you are fully-equipped with a battle pack and laser gun. The game can be high-intensity, unnerving, and is intended to pump up your adrenaline. You are given a name like “Ninja,” “Neo,” or “Shuttle” and sent out to shoot at opposing players. There are often two modes, where you can either play in teams or it’s “every man for himself.” Ultimately, laser tag draws you in by convincing you that you are actually playing within a different world, much like virtual reality. Laser Tag transports you to this space where everything looks different, and the sounds are different. It’s definitely an interesting mix between reality and video games. It exists in a space between the two areas. Strategy is also a very important part of laser tag. The more strategic and stealthy you are in your movements, the more likely you are to come in first or second place.

Weekly Research Week 12

NEWMAN, JAMES, and IAIN SIMONS. “Using the Force: LEGO Star Wars: The Video Game, Intertextuality, Narrative, and Play.” New Narratives: Stories and Storytelling in the Digital Age, edited by RUTH PAGE and BRONWEN THOMAS, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln; London, 2011, pp. 239–253. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1df4h49.18.

This article discusses how some Star Wars video games break the boundaries of the traditional canon of Star Wars, and have became an important part of transmedial storytelling. This means that the bad characters don’t always have to be bad, and the good characters don’t always have to be good. It is an interesting way to approach Star Wars in a completely different way. Especially with LEGO now incorporating the Star Wars brand into its movies and games, the way that people see and interactive with Star Wars is completely different due to the complexity of these video games.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/j.ctt1df4h49.18.pdf

Rhetorical Analysis #9

The physical space of play has a lot to do with how we experience games. Often times, a player can enjoy play more if he/she is in a comfortable environment/position. A lot of video games can be played sitting down, but some, like specific arcade video games such as PacMan, etc., are played standing up. What does the arcade environment do to the space of play? It makes it more social. A video game arcade is a space dedicated to creating a social gaming environment. It’s unique, nostalgic, and a little archaic, but still fun. Arcades can encourage physical social interaction while playing. The way that arcades are are set up encourages others to watch an individual who is playing the game, thus becoming the player’s audience. It doesn’t always have to happen this way, but the arcade seems to be an accepted place for this. The mood and atmosphere of the arcade creates a social space where others can come together to experience games as either the player or the audience.

Weekly Research Week 11

Alexandra Henning, et al. “Do Stereotypic Images in Video Games Affect Attitudes and Behavior? Adolescent Perspectives.” Children, Youth and Environments, vol. 19, no. 1, 2009, pp. 170–196. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/10.7721/chilyoutenvi.19.1.0170.

This article outlines a study done on the affects that video game images have on adolescent attitudes and behavior. The study found that, in a week, males played games more than twice as much as females. The negative stereotypes portrayed through video games (especially as they pertain to gender roles), seemed to have less of an affect on males who played games often. Thus, males were less likely to evaluate video games in a negative way and, instead, took these stereotypes at face-value and tended not to question or critique them. This poses a problem for developing adolescents who are exposed to these stereotypes without issue.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/10.7721/chilyoutenvi.19.1.0170.pdf

Rhetorical Analysis #8

Twitch is a site dedicated to interactive online video game streaming. It was recently bought by Amazon for around 970 million dollars. My question is: what does this online platform do to the space of play? If players are streaming their playtime live on screen for others to see, then how do other’s interactions with the game affect the way the player plays? How do these online gaming communities expand the space of play? I think that websites such as Twitch can enhance the motivation of a play only in the sense of achievement or ego-boosts a player gets while performing for an audience. However, this leads me to think that Twitch makes play a more superficial performative act once it is broadcasted out. In this sense, does Twitch transform the space of play into instant-gratification? Does play, then, become more about showing skill to viewers than it does about actually defeating the game?

Weekly Research Week 10

Hoffman, Bobby, and Louis Nadelson. “Motivational Engagement and Video Gaming: a Mixed Methods Study.” Educational Technology Research and Development, vol. 58, no. 3, 2010, pp. 245–270. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/40603176.

This article highlights a study done on the effects of motivational engagement in video games. Among these motivations were self-esteem boosts and enhanced competency (246). Because of these motivations, the article argues that gamers are more engaged in the gaming experience. The article then goes on to provide quantitative research and data regarding the study. What the study concludes is that gamers need to obtain a certain amount of control within the game in order to feel some type of psychological achievement. It also showed how much gamers depend on socializations within the game to satisfy certain needs.

http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/40603176.pdf

Rhetorical Analysis #7

While video games come with an array of graphics, there is one thing that a lot have in common: bright colors. Games such as Candy Crush use bright colors to stimulate the the player’s vision, allowing for more visually-appealing game play. But what is the strategy behind these bright colors? Why are they there, and what do they do? Essentially, in color theory, colors set the mood or tone. Usually, in video games, the colors and the background music go hand-in-hand. In Candy Crush, the bright colors are accompanied by happy music. Colors can certainly have an emotional response ; the bright colors in Candy Crush seek to appeal to happy emotions (as does the music). In this way, color theory is an important rhetorical strategy in video games. If the goal is to insight a specific emotion, that emotion’s coordinating colors should be used. In Candy Crush, the bright colors are supposed to insight joyful emotions.

Weekly Research Week 9

Candy Crush. King. 12 April 2012. Video game.

Candy Crush can be an addictive game. It is a puzzle game, with each level setting a different objective. The player is not supposed to clear the entire board, but is, instead, prompted to crush certain blocks of candy or eliminate certain ingredients. With over 2,000 levels, this game has essentially unlimited game-play. It is different than most games because there is not a clear end-goal; you just keep beating levels and playing on to the next level. Consequently, there has never been anyone that has “won” Candy Crush. This game proves an important point that games are still enjoyable even if they do not have a clear end result.

https://king.com/game/candycrush

Rhetorical Analysis #6

Earlier in the semester, I did a rhetorical analysis of the Battlefield 1 trailer. I thought it would be interesting to do an analysis of the actual game.

Battlefield 1 is a high-intensity game, meant to be extremely realistic. The graphics are so good, it makes you feel like you’re actually within the game. Since the graphics are so realistic, there are times when playing gets a little unnerving. Because you can have an array of weapons, like knives, axes, etc., when you attack someone with these weapons, it looks like you’re actually attacking them. In the same way, if you get attacked, the screen spins around and simulates an actual attack. The music that plays in the background is also very ominous, fueling feelings of uneasiness and panic. Battlefield 1 seeks to simulate the same emotions that you would feel when watching an action movie, except now you’re playing a part in that movie. In the future, I think games such as this can develop, using virtual reality technology, to simulate emotions similar to those felt in actual combat situations. Games like that, then, could be used to potentially emotionally prepare soldiers for combat situations.

Weekly Research Week 8

Jolley, Kristie. “Video Games to Reading: Reaching out to Reluctant Readers.” The English Journal, vol. 97, no. 4, 2008, pp. 81–86. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/30047252.

This article examines the role that video games have in helping students with learning difficulties become better readers. Jolley claims that there is a connection between the gaming habits and schoolwork of an individual(81). Using James Paul Gee’s approach to learning and literacy and how he realizes the importance of recognizing games as teachable texts, Jolley surveyed 250 eight-grade students in her school about their reading and gaming habits. This empirical research concluded that students who love video games but struggle to read are more excited to read game-based books. These books (such as novels based off of the Halo video game), actually have authority and power within the reading classroom. She also explains that teachers can reach out to the students who are more game-based by having them read graphic novels. What Jolley concludes is that the role of video games can have an impact on literacy of an individual if that role is catered to appropriately within the school environment.

Rhetorical Analysis #5

Nancy Drew: The Ghost of Thornton Hall already has your ethos established from the start: you’re Nancy Drew…acclaimed teenage detective. The rest of the game prompts you to live up to that ethos through critical thinking, problem-solving, and keen observation skills. By assuming the role of Nancy Drew from the start, the ultimate goal is to find out who is haunting Thornton Hall and find the missing bride-to-be. The game needs you to be active and productive at all times; every puzzle, conversation, and in-game text serves a purpose. The best way to solve the mystery is to take note of everything. When I first started playing this gaming series when I was in elementary school, I would create sheets of notes. Anything I saw I wrote down because I needed to remember it all. This helped me beat the earlier games. As I got more well-versed in these games, I relied less and less on my note-taking and more on my learned abilities and experiences from previous game play. These games prompted me to be more observant, showing me the importance of observation skills.

Final Copy: Project 1

Here is the final draft of my website: Gaming, Literacy, and Dominance.

Process Points:

  1. Topic Proposal, containing a topic, a working thesis, and at least one primary (game object) and secondary source shared via the weekly blogs, no later than 1159 9/29 (5%) YES
  2. Presentation of topic proposal, in class 10/3 (5 %) YES
  3. Defense of topic proposal in conference with me no later than 10/3 (5%) YES
  4. A draft project overview with a thesis and and no fewer than 200 words, shared on our weekly blogs no later than 10/6 (5%) YES
  5. Commenting on two other writing projects via the blogs, on or before 10/8 (5%); YES (commented on Elliot and Domenico’s projects)
  6. A draft conference with me, on or before 10/6 (5%) YES
  7. Another draft conference with me, showing a substantially finished draft of the project, on or before 10/13 (5%); YES
  8. A near-final draft, shared/linked from a post on our shared blog, on or before 10/13 (5%); YES
  9. A final round of commenting on two drafts, due on or before 10/14 (5%); YES (commented on James & Alexa’s projects)

Weekly Research Week 7

https://tetris.com/play-tetris

Tetris is probably one of the most-played games ever, but it is crucial in the development of visual and technological literacies. Tetris can be played across a variety of technologies including computers, phones, gaming consoles, arcade devices. It is essentially a timed puzzle game, prompting the player to make choices in how to they want the falling pieces to fit into place. In this way, it prompts the player to make quick decisions; there is not a lot of time to think. This teaches the player how to visually assess the empty spaces and fill them accordingly, thus teaching visual literacy.

Weekly Research Week 6

Galloway, Alexander R. “Social Realism.” Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture, NED – New edition ed., vol. 18, University of Minnesota Press, 2006, pp. 70–84. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctttss5p.7.

In this article, Galloway discusses the relationship between the physical world and the world of gaming. He focuses on games that provide real life situations and those that are simply grounded in fantasy, and applies each of these to social realism (art that depicts modern life for social or political persuasions). Because games are not only visual, but also require a certain amount of physical action, Galloway concludes that video games, such as those that train military personel, provide the player with a sense of “realism in action” (84). He then goes on to claim that video games are mediums through which players are encouraged to perform actions, which makes them valid and important forms of social realism.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/10.5749/j.ctttss5p.7.pdf?refreqid=search%3Ab7bacb8a61a1e58da348f7ad24f81821

 

 

Project One Rough Draft/Thesis #1

Since the introduction of digital gaming in 1958, video games have expanded the space of play, forging a strong relationship between physical and digital worlds. With the increasing dependence on technology as a whole, it certainly follows that we can now look to technological spaces for personal development and growth. Theoretically, the mental aspects of play-through-gaming can develop the mind in ways that traditional learning spaces cannot, because players have to, for example, learn to think quickly and critically in short periods of time in order to complete a certain task. However, “games are [also] an active medium that requires constant physical input by the player: action, doing, pressing buttons, controlling, and so on” (Galloway 83). Therefore, this combination of mental and physical engagement creates a foundation for growth in many different types of literacies. Games teach us visual, critical, technological, and linguistic literacies that further help us to develop not only how we play games, but how we enjoy play. Furthermore, Jonathan Alexander makes a brief suggestion in his article that people may not necessarily be addicted to the video games, but to play itself (36). Although the word addiction may be a bit ambitious, Alexander is getting to a valid point. The literacies learned from games help the player to enjoy play more because they are actively understanding both the technological, linguistic, and visual spaces within the game, which then gives them governance within the game. These literacies can also certainly carry over into the real-world, providing players with advantages in school, career, and relationships. Furthermore, the more technologically literate an individual is, the better equipped they are at operating within our technologically dependent society.

Thesis: Therefore, it is the literacy-aspects learned through game play that breed competence, allowing the player to expand understanding of technology, mature linguistic practices, and garner critical skills which allows for success not only within the game but within the real world as well. This gives meaning to play while fulfilling one of the most important psychological aspects of play: dominance.

Weekly Research Week 5

De Vore, Paul W. “Technological Literacy and Social Purpose.” Theory Into Practice, vol. 31, 1, 1992, pp. 59–63. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/1477055.

Technological literacy is one type of literacy that I will be discussing and exploring in my first project. The article states that we have now evolved to depend on technology so much, that failure to educate and stay up-to-date on technological literacies will impair social status. We have now come to recognize technological literacy “as a part of basic literacy” (61). This type of literacy, therefore, must become part of the education curriculum, and this article gives guidelines for such curricula. Although this article does not deal directly with video games, it can be argued that video games can be used in curricula to teach technological literacy.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/1477055.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A67d7f0d1be8669a4ceda82060f21799e

 

 

Rhetorical Analysis #4: Dance Dance Revolution

DDR (released for Playstation in 1999) was one of the first games that encouraged active exercise and rhythm within game play. It deviated from traditional games in that it made the feet and legs control the game, instead of the hands and fingers. DDR pioneered the dance genre of video games, necessitating the player to get off their couches in order to play. What DDR succeeded in doing was to encourage the gamer to actively exercise while gaming. This exercise/gaming experience then introduced a healthy/active aspect to game play, and forged the idea that a video game could potentially be a healthy activity for the body. DDR strategically persuaded its players that exercising while gaming could be active, engaging, and rewarding. Although it was not necessarily marketed as a way to exercise, a player could potentially burn hundreds of calories during prolonged periods of play. DDR encouraged these long periods of play through lightning graphics and enjoyable songs, all meant to pump up adrenaline and almost addict the player to the game. Thus, while the appeal of DDR might not necessarily be excerise, it succeeds in providing its players hours of gameplay which just so happens to be exercise as well.

Topic Proposal Project 1

For my first project, I want to focus on literacy and gaming. There are a lot of resources that suggest that gaming promotes a variety of different literacies, which is an important component of gaming that is most often defended by those who encourage gaming as a tool for learning outside of the classroom. I want to look deeper into the types of literacies that games promote; not just reading and understanding texts but using them as tools/guidelines for understanding play and manipulating the landscape/storyline of the game itself. Games teach us visual, critical, technological, and digital literacies that further help us develop not only how we play games, but how we enjoy play. Furthermore, Jonathan Alexander makes a brief suggestion that people may not necessarily be addicted to the games, but to play itself (“Gaming, Student Literacies…” 36). The literacies learned from games help the player to enjoy play more because they are understanding both the technical and linguistic aspects of the game which gives them dominance within the game. But, also, these literacies can certainly carry over into the real-world, and give players an upper-hand in school, career, relationships, and life in general. If gamers are reading and understanding texts outside of their normal linguistic spaces while applying this understanding to the game, and, at the same time, developing critical thinking skills which help them to succeed and achieve goals, these literacies will undoubtedly fulfill a type of self-realization and power.

Therefore, I want to argue that it is the literacy-aspects learned through game play that yield addiction to play, because these literacies allow the player to expand understanding, gain knowledge, and ultimately succeed not only in the game but in the real world as well. This gives the play meaning and fulfills the player’s desire for dominance (psychological aspect of play), while also giving them real-world skills which may enhance their lives.

Primary Sources

Murray, Janet H. Hamlet on the holodeck: The future of narrative in cyberspace. MIT press, 2017.

Gee, James Paul. What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy. Macmillan, 2014.

Secondary Source

Alexander, Jonathan. “Gaming, Student Literacies, and the Composition Classroom: Some Possibilities for Transformation.” College Composition and Communication, vol. 61, no. 1, 2009, pp. 35–63. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/40593514.

Potential Games

DDR

Nancy Drew (PC game)

Weekly Research Week 4

Alexander, Jonathan. “Gaming, Student Literacies, and the Composition Classroom: Some Possibilities for Transformation.” College Composition and Communication, vol. 61, no. 1, 2009, pp. 35–63. JSTOR, JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/40593514.

This article explores the type of literacy that can be learned through games. The author claims that gamers must think critically, and must use coordination and collaboration with other players in order to perform specific tasks (especially in multi player games). The article suggests a study that explains that games have become a more popular source of not only entertainment, but also community building and socializing. Because games are often full of text, they can also promote literacy as well. There are three types of literacies involved in gaming: visual, technological, and textual (36). Thus, gaming involves both literacy and rhetoric “in action” (37). The author brings up a good point too, that sometimes people are not necessarily addicted to the game, but play itself (36).

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/40593514.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A450c02228346a112552189534951c626

 

Rhetorical Analysis #3: The Gaming Chair

There are chairs specifically designed for gamers. Through the way they are designed and marketed, they encourage the gamer to play for longer periods of time by increasing comfort levels. They are usually marketed as ergonomic and relaxing, and are designed to provide support for the lower back, neck, and head. Sometimes they even recline or have wheels (my cousin even had one with built-in fans). This is one aspect of gaming/play that is interesting. The gamer’s experience/comfortability while engaging in play enhances the gaming experience as whole by providing appropriate back, head, and neck support. If the player is constantly hunched over or uncomfortable while gaming, they may not notice or even realize how much this strains the neck and back, and affects healthy posture. Thus, the chairs are also designed with health goals in mind. Keeping the player in an appropriate position allows not only for healthy posture but proper blood flow to all parts of the body. It is important to understand the health implications that can occur from poor gaming posture/position. These chairs succeed at addressing and correcting these issues while providing comfort for the player at the same time.

https://www.houzz.com/photos/94221954/BTEXPERT-Ergonomic-Leather-Gaming-Chair-Napping-Pillow-Headrest-Lumbar-Support-contemporary-gaming-chairs

 

Weekly Research Week 3

Adams, Megan Glover. “Engaging 21st-Century Adolescents: Video Games in the Reading Classroom.” The English Journal, vol. 98, no. 6, 2009, pp. 56–59. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/40503460.

Adams argues that since most students find more enjoyment in technology, utilizing video games as a way of learning has become increasingly important. She argues that games such as Neverwinter Nights not only help students with reading and problem solving, but in these games they also enter into a new linguistic space where they must learn and incorporate new words. Playing video games includes a lot of reading, so the incorporation of games in the classroom allows students to develop their reading skills. In doing so, video games create a sort of “virtual literacy” which Adams says “requires that students extend their understanding of technology to include understanding how to use it responsibly and how to ‘read’ authors’ intentions by making inferences and comprehending the codes involved in the online world” (58).

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/40503460.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A8c3d8b3c32d9120678aefb40eb49903f

Battlefield 1 Trailer Rhetorical Analysis

The preview for Xbox’s Battlefield 1 game, is clearly created to look like a movie trailer, with the exception that we are also invited to interact with the action. The trailer persuades us to partake in the actions of the game through a few different strategies. The first being a perspective strategy. Since the commercial is seen through a first-person perspective, it feels like we are already a vital part of the game, thus making us feel important and needed within the game. The next approach appeals to our emotions through the portrayal of action and crises, set to a remixed version of The White Stripes “Seven Nation Army.” This song acts as a battle call, and, mixed with the chaos, is intended to amp up our adrenaline. The realistic graphics also make the game feel as real as possible. Because it simulates actual historical events as well, perhaps there is the appeal of time-travel in that we as players could potentially recreate historic battles. All of these approaches succeed in bringing us as close as we can into the story, before we even pick up our controllers to play.

Weekly Research Week 2

Nicholson, Scott. “Reframing Gaming.” American Libraries, vol. 39, no. 7, 2008, pp. 50–51. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/25650027.

This article examines the role that games play within libraries. It is noted that games have been included in libraries since the 1800s (where they were more traditional, like cricket). Gaming can, in fact, create a community of people from different backgrounds who come together for a common goal/purpose. What is interesting is that this article reframes gaming as “participatory storytelling,” in that the creator of the game sets up the story, and we as players participate in exploring the story. There seems to be a commonality amongst the articles I have come across, and that is the argument that games allow us to engage with an atmosphere that we would not normally be present in, and explore this as a different type of social interaction.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/25650027.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A03b5fc5f08ea0bc4b7bc376669c8ba97

Hayley Annino

Weekly Research 9/5

Shaffer, David Williamson, et al. “Video Games and the Future of Learning.” The Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 87, no. 2, 2005, pp. 104–111. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/20441942.

This article argues that videogames can be an important tool in learning, especially since we are coming into an age where so much of the way we interact and engage is digitized. As a new type of social interaction, video games let the players “participate in new worlds” (105) and allows he or she to engage in new roles that otherwise could not be experienced by him or her. This helps the player learn and grow, especially if these games are catered to something specific (critical thinking, team-building, etc.). Ideally, games will evolve to include specific practice in fields of study like medicine or architecture, while building communities of gamers as well. This article looks at gaming as a positive asset to learning, and a transformative practice.

http://www.jstor.org.proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/stable/pdf/20441942.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A9191a35a4b8c0766aefda25ceddeb1c1

Hayley Annino

Rhetorical Analysis 9/4

Simple and to the point, Smith’s definition of rhetoric is one that every reader can understand. However, as her text progresses, its purpose shifts and expands to include a variety of different views on rhetoric. By offering varying opinions on the topic, it seems as though Smith wants to provide us with its many different facets so that we may come to our own conclusions and definitions…but that is not necessarily what she is doing. What Smith communicates is her belief that rhetoric, in its best form, “enhances” “truth” and “beauty.” She throws this in, a little more than halfway down the page, and then sandwiches it under bullet points headed by words like “deny” and “defame.” But this statement is neither denial or defamation of rhetoric, it exemplifies the beauty of it. Therefore, I think that at the heart of her argument, Smith uses our emotions to persuade us into believing, I gather, what she believes is the best form and function of rhetoric: one which “enhances” “truth” and “beauty.” She wants the reader to believe this too, as she strategically places it at the center of her text without explicitly placing it in her defintion.

Hayley Annino

css.php