Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101
AUSTIN – Weekly Writing for Rhetoric of Gaming F2017

Project 2

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y5T_CPDipVTjJbbxC8jMpbj7eBcRfKZfqlGA4pnBN-s/edit?usp=sharing

  1. Topic Proposal, containing a topic, a working thesis, and at least one primary (game object) and secondary source shared via the weekly blogs, no later than 1159 11/29 (5%) YES
  2. Presentation of topic proposal, in class 11/30 (5 %) YES
  3. Defense of topic proposal  in conference with me no later than 11/29 (5%) YES
  4. An initial draft project in the format it will be submitted (either google docs or web page) linked from the blogs no later than 12/5 (5%) YES
  5. Commenting on two other writing projects via the blogs, on or before 12/8 (5%);YES
  6. A draft conference with me, on or before 12/8, show substantial progress on a drafted project (5%) YES
  7. A near-final draft, shared/linked from a post on our shared blog, on or before 12/13 (5%); YES
  8. A final round of commenting on two drafts, due on or before 12/15 (5%); YES
  9. The quality of the finished project, due on 12/16 (55%) YES

 

Project 2 Rough Draft – Intro Paragraphs

Video games can cause a plethora of emotions in the player. Emotional deaths in a game’s story have reduced the manliest of men to mere blubbering babies. Wining a well fought battle or completing an arduous task causes a swell of pride and happiness in the player. But these emotions play second fiddle to the most common in video games: rage. Every gamer has experienced the burning desire to throw controllers, scream at the screen, or send hate mail to an opponent who was obviously better than them. With more and more multiplayer modes being the prominent aspect of a video game, sending hate mail is becoming the more popular option. Also, controllers are much more expensive than what they used to be so throwing and breaking one would possibly break the bank.

I get hate mail at least once whenever I play XBox and sometimes even more than that. No matter if I do well or if I don’t perform that well, hate mail will be sent around. If I perform well, hate mail tends to  be sent from the other team. If I perform terribly, hate mail can either be sent from the other team or even my own teammates. Also, the frequency of hate mail primarily depends on the game I play. More intense games with competitive rankings in their multiplayer modes like Rainbow Six Siege and Overwatch give rise to more negative communication between team members and opponents. Casual games less focused on rankings like Rocket League and Halo have less of an opportunity and less frequent hate messaging. The gameplay aspects of these games can lead to the creation the personality of the game’s surrounding communities. Certain communities are known for being more toxic while others are more relaxed. The different mechanics in the gameplay lead to how aggressive or casual their surrounding communities can be.

Project 2 – Proposal

For my project, I want to explore the differences in game play and their surrounding communities. Certain games have different kinds of players and varying aggression from those players. In specific video games, the players are serious as can be whereas in other games, the surrounding social communities are relaxed. I want to explore why this is and what causes these differences in communities through the game play.

Video Game for research – Rainbow Six Siege, Rocket League

Secondary Source for research – Exploring success factors of video game communities in hierarchical linear modeling: The perspectives of members and leaders (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0747563209000302?via%3Dihub)

Rhetorical Analysis – Overwatch

https://playoverwatch.com/en-us/

The main basis of play in Overwatch stems from the multiplayer aspects, primarily the quickplay or competitive game modes. These two modes have similar play styles with the only difference being match length. Quickplay or competitive either utilizes an “escort the payload” or a “capture the point” type of game where there is a defending team and a offensive team. In this, there are over 20 different kinds of characters with differing abilities and skill sets. The different abilities is impactful for players in one of two ways: either their character fits that person’s play style or they know what would aid their team toward victory. This also embraces teamwork and teams that work together  and communicate are often met with victory. This gives the player an identity to latch onto while emphasizing team work through its game modes. The identity is either met through the category of player they choose or the literal character they choose.

Weekly Research – Overwatch

https://playoverwatch.com/en-us/

Overwatch is a multiplayer based game through and through. There is no such thing as a campaign for the game and there aren’t any game modes for single player in any function other than a free for all mode. That’s the most “single-player” any player is going to get. What’s interesting is that there is a story to the game, there is a reason for every character being in the game, and there is a reason for every objective in the multiplayer matches. There is a ton of lore that is communicated through animation short movies, dialogue between characters, and information shown in the game. But most importantly, the game is centered the cooperation of the respective teams. The game is based on character-specific abilities, so the combination of character abilities between players is the easiest path to success for their teams. Teams need to communicate about timing and strategy to achieve victory in the different game modes in Overwatch.

Weekly Analysis – The Stanley Parable

https://www.stanleyparable.com

The main concept of The Stanley Parable that is brought to the surface is the concept of choice. With the narrator “telling you what to do”, the player begins to think about different possible choices within the game. They could do what they want to and disregard the narrator or do they follow the narrator and disregard what the player wants or a combination of the two. Then, when deciding between the two options, the game provokes existential questions in the player (or at least it did for me). Such as are humans making their own choices or are we following the orders of another person? And is that person following the orders of another person and so on and so on. Because this concept is being translated into game play. Another concept to think about with this game is about the definition of winning. There are over 16 possible endings for the player to achieve but after each ending, the game restarts and that’s it – that’s the game. A lot of the definitions of games that we have read so far include the requirement of a sense of victory in a game. Based on that, the argument can be made that this game is not a game at all unless a player can find a way to find victory in this game.

Weekly Research – The Stanley Parable

https://www.stanleyparable.com

The Stanley Parable is an interactive fiction based video game that follows the main character, aptly named, Stanley. One day at work, Stanley shows up and begins to complete the work that he is told to do. After a while, he notices that the entire office is abandoned. He then begins to investigate the situation and this is where the game begins. There is a narrator that will give you ideas as to where to go or what to do next. The interesting part of the game lies within the player’s reaction and relationship with the narrator. The player can follow whatever the narrator says or they can choose to blatantly ignore the narrator’s suggestions or they could even do the exact opposite of what the narrator tells them to do. Based on their according actions, the narrator will speak in a passive tone, hinting towards the player or will address the player directly. Also, there is no technical winning of the game. There are multiple endings but there is no way to win because at the end of every ending, the game will restart. The concept of choice and winning is brought to the surface by this game.

Weekly Analysis

Call of Duty: World War II – https://www.callofduty.com/wwii

As a die-hard fan of the original Call of Duty game play in games like Modern Warfare and World at War, I couldn’t be happier to see the Call of Duty franchise return to its traditional way of play. The recent games were fun to play but the movement mechanics brought me out of the game. In older Call of Duty games, I got consumed in the game play because of the small details that made the game play feel more real. Details like my character gets tired after sprinting for a while and would stop, the sway of a sniper scope when trying to pin point a distant shot, and the gore helped build the world in game play because they were aspects that I would expect from real world war. I would see other players get their legs blown off during a multiplayer match and in recent games, that wasn’t the case. I would shoot somebody in the kneecaps with a 12-gauge shotgun and the enemy player would fly back like a rag-doll. In real world experiences, the enemy should have no legs and the realistic consequences in the older games are what brought me in to the game play, ultimately investing me into the game further.

Weekly Research – Call of Duty WWII

Call of Duty: World War II – https://www.callofduty.com/wwii

One of the biggest names in the gaming industry has created yet another installment, its fourteenth to be exact with Call of Duty: World War II. The significance behind this release is the return to Call of Duty’s or CoD’s traditional sense of game play. The original few CoD titles were known for their realistic take on a first person shooter game revolving around actual warfare. After the tide of first person shooters became more about the fast-paced movement and shooting with games like Titanfall, CoD adopted that function of game play. Recently, CoD games had featured incredible movement such as double jumping, wall running, and unlimited sprint. This change was received with mixed reactions and a lot of original lovers of the first couple CoD games were disappointed. Those fans are pleasantly surprised in the recent release with the same mechanics of older CoD releases such as boots on the ground action, a gritty and realistic campaign, and a World War II centered game. Even the infamous Nazi Zombies mode has been given a revamp and is more gruesome than it has ever been.

Weekly Analysis

Robbins, M. Brandon. “Puzzle It out.” Library Journal, vol. 141, no. 7, 15 Apr. 2016, p. 60. EBSCOhost, proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=114555334&site=ehost-live&scope=site.

As far as academic research goes, this article felt pretty lacking. There wasn’t any research cited to help further the point of the article or establish any credibility. The writing wasn’t even that in depth and took most aspects of the game at face value. The article overall felt like it was written as an editorial piece in a newspaper. After re-reading the article for the third or fourth time, I felt a little bad about myself for enjoying it so much on the first read because it doesn’t really have much to offer. I still think the article made some successful points about the game it mentioned. I think it was successful in bringing the sense of a puzzle being hidden within a first person shooter game to light by providing examples and descriptions of the game-play. The article still needs to cite some academic, peer-reviewed research to gain any credibility regarding these points.

Weekly Research

Robbins, M. Brandon. “Puzzle It out.” Library Journal, vol. 141, no. 7, 15 Apr. 2016, p. 60. EBSCOhost, proxy-wcupa.klnpa.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=114555334&site=ehost-live&scope=site.

In this article, M. Brandon Robbins writes about the evolution of puzzle games all the way from classics like Tetris to newer indie puzzle games like The Talos Principle. He talks about a newer puzzle game that hides it puzzle genre under the disguise of a first person shooter. Superhot is a level-based game where the player must shoot their way through different areas to move on to the next level. The player can slow down time amongst other video-game-esque mechanics but this time-slowing effect helps to figure out the puzzle aspect of the game. The player must identify patterns and manipulate elements within the shooting to maneuver through the levels. Robbins also cites the story to be a puzzle in a way. Players must piece the entire story together through clues and cryptic messages along the progression of the story. He says the game entices players  that primarily stick to a first person shooter type game to go out of their comfort zone and take up a more puzzle based game while sticking to some of the mechanics they are used to.

Analysis – Resident Evil’s Rhetoric

Resident Evil’s Rhetoric: The Communication of Corruption in Survival Horror Video Games by Charley Reed http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1555412015575363

This article thoroughly analyzes the effectiveness of Resident Evil’s infliction of terror upon the gamer. I’ve always known Resident Evil to be a horror game but I found new aspects in this article that I’ve never though of. What the article does best is just that, it goes past the normal factors of a horror game and analyzes the small and minute details that add to the terror that most gamers would even notice. The fact that the author notes the process of finding information through physical objects shows the real interest and investigation this author dealt with to complete this article. Citing something I would have never thought of gives the impression that the author really delved into the substance of their knowledge and the corresponding game. Writing about the idea of corruption in the game also gives the author credibility. Anyone can note that the surroundings in the Resident Evil games are creepy because they are dark, mysterious, and just all around creepy. This author goes in depth about the corruption of nature, architecture, and relating characters that cause the overall feeling of terror. The depth of their discussions establishes the authors credibility and gives the impression that the author really wants to investigate the game deeply.

Weekly Research – Week 8

Resident Evil’s Rhetoric: The Communication of Corruption in Survival Horror Video Games by Charley Reed http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1555412015575363

Charley Reed investigates and dissects what really makes a horror video game incite a sense of dread and terror in his article Resident Evil’s Rhetoric: The Communication of Corruption in Survival Horror Video Games. Using different rhetoric theories and ideals, he delves into the different aspects and mechanisms of the game franchise that really add to the sense of dread and terror when a player invests themselves in the game. One characteristic that adds to a player’s sense of terror is how the aspects of play and story break our preconceived notions about behavior and life. Things are scarier to players when they don’t adhere to normal life, leaving the player out of control of the story and unable to expect what comes next. Another interesting point Reed pointed out is that in Resident Evil games, backstory and expositional information is normally found within non-digital objects. Players find information through books, paintings, pictures, or tape recordings found throughout the game. This grounds the game for the player making the aspect of finding information feel real. Finding information in a digital fashion like through computers in a digital outlet like an Xbox feels less real than finding physical information in a digital outlet.

Final Website

Completed all process points except for number 7

  1. Topic Proposal, containing a topic, a working thesis, and at least one primary (game object) and secondary source shared via the weekly blogs, no later than 1159 9/29 (5%)
  2. Presentation of topic proposal, in class 10/3 (5 %)
  3. Defense of topic proposal  in conference with me no later than 10/3 (5%)
  4. A draft project overview with a thesis and and no fewer than 200 words, shared on our weekly blogs no later than 10/6 (5%)
  5. Commenting on two other writing projects via the blogs, on or before 10/8 (5%);
  6. A draft conference with me, on or before 10/6 (5%)
  7. Another draft conference with me, showing a substantially finished draft of the project, on or before 10/13 (5%);
  8. A near-final draft, shared/linked from a post on our shared blog, on or before 10/13 (5%);
  9. A final round of commenting on two drafts, due on or before 10/14 (5%);

Welcome!

Closer to Finish Draft (Mostly a basis for my analysis parargaphs)

I remember my first console: Playstation 2. I remember my first favorite game: Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus. I remember the first game that I ever played online with friends: Call of Duty: World at War. I also remember the first Xbox controller I broke from throwing it on the ground in rage. I was quickly lectured by my very angry father but I can wholeheartedly say that I have learned from my situation and never broken a controller since. Besides learning the value of a $60 controller, from all of my gaming experience I have learned so much from playing video games contrary to my father’s belief.

Games have taught me cognitive skills ever since I could hold a controller. I’ve learned about problem-solving, spatial awareness, and motivation more from playing games like Sly Cooper for an hour than playing baseball for a decade. I still learn new things from games now. It may seem like I’m just playing a game but after reflecting on the gameplay I had just experienced, games are much deeper than I perceive. Games like Assassin’s Creed have taught me about history and culture, Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice has taught me about mental illness, and games like Minecraft have taught me about creativity. With the new advancements in the video game world, games should be as complex as their operating systems and most of the time, they are.

 

“Using sources from class, talk about what makes a game then transition into my game analyses.”

 

The game franchise that has since blown up continually teaches players about history and culture in a way that any high school history teacher cannot. Assassin’s Creed follows the Assassin Brotherhood as it evolves through different eras and locations. The first installment followed the third Crusade in Jerusalem, the second followed the Renaissance in Italy, the third followed the colonization of America, and so on and so on. The best thing about this franchise is the way it follows history and also creates their own history. This teaches the player about the history revolving around the setting of the game while also creating a quasi-fictional world and story to draw the player in. Kurt Squire quotes a fellow writer Loewen in his book, Video Games and Learning: Teaching and Participatory Culture in the Digital Age, “Loewen begins his book “Lies My Teacher Told Me with ‘High school students hate history. When they list their favorite subjects, history invariably comes in last….Bor-r-ring is the adjective they commonly apply to it’(p.12)” (111). History lessons need a reboot and I can entirely relate with these surveyed children.

History has always helped put into a good mid-school nap. But once I came across the wonders of Assassin’s Creed II, I fell into a historical hole regarding Leonardo Da Vinci. Your source of technological and weapon advancements in the game revolves around Leonardo Da Vinci. Ask any person about Good ol’ Leo and they’ll immediately respond with something about his paintings. Leo’s character in AC2 doesn’t even reference his paintings because, what many people do not know about him is that he was also a master inventor. Leo actually sketched what is believed to be the first helicopter, he invented the parachute, and he invented the giant crossbow. All of this learning was inspired from my first mission where I meet Leo and he crafts my hidden assassin blade, something a boring, hour-long history lecture couldn’t have done for me.

Kurt Squire also writes about using Civilization 3 as a teaching outlet for kids. He found the children learned about the resources or certain advances of the respective regions in Civ3 without knowing it and then Squire and the teachers capitalized on those lessons by furthering their new-found knowledge. One kid said, “Location is important. Playing in America was easier”. To which Squire explained the player acknowledged the importance of scientific discovery  and how America’s role in scientific discoveries helped their play in the game. Other players liked playing in Egypt because of their surplus of gold where the teachers then taught the players about the importance of the Nile River and the Egyptian and their reliance on gold. When reflecting on his tests, Squire explains, “We tried many teaching approaches, but found the most success when teaching and learning activities were in direct response to game play challenges” (138). So when these teachers combined a lesson with the game, it helped solidify all of the information those children learned through playing this video game.

Weekly Research

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal_(video_game)

Portal is crazy fun game. This puzzle based game has a certain aesthetic that appeals to the eye while the mind-bending spatial puzzles appeal to the mind. There isn’t much story given to the player other than you are a test subject that is supposed to complete certain puzzles while using a portal gun. The portal gun can create two teleportation portals where one leads to the other and vice versa. The character that you play as doesn’t say much, in fact nothing at all, but the game is narrated by an artificial intelligence called GLaDOS which stands for Genetic Lifeform and Disk Operating System. She has a monotone and apathetic voice where she directs you through the game until you find out something just isn’t right. Your character breaks out of the testing facilities to ultimately defeat GLaDOS using the same mechanics that you’ve used to get to her and the game ends in a very vague way by your character ending up on the outside of the facility. Re-playing this game for my project research made me realize the complexity of the story and how really hard the puzzles seem to be. I felt like I better understood them when I was younger.

Draft (Intro Paragraphs)

I remember my first console: Playstation 2. I remember my first favorite game: Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus. I remember the first game that I ever played online with my friends: Call of Duty: World at War. I also remember the first Xbox controller I broke from throwing it on the ground in rage. I was quickly lectured by my very angry father but I can wholeheartedly say that I have learned from my situation and never broken a controller since. Besides learning the value of a $60 controller, from all of my gaming experience I have learned so much from playing video games contrary to my father’s belief.

Games have taught me cognitive skills ever since I could hold a controller. I’ve learned about problem-solving, spatial awareness, and motivation more from playing games like Sly Cooper for an hour than playing baseball for a decade. I still learn new things from games now. It may seem like I’m just playing a game but after reflecting on the gameplay I had just experienced, games are much deeper than I perceive. Games like Assassin’s Creed have taught me about history and culture, Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice has taught me about mental illness, and games like Minecraft have taught me about creativity. With the new advancements in the video game world, games should be as complex as their operating systems and most of the time, they are.

Weekly Research

Assassin’s Creed 2 – Xbox One

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassin%27s_Creed_II

Assassin’s Creed has created multiple installments to it’s franchise but one of the most notable games in this franchise is Assassin’s Creed 2. The story of Assassin’s Creed begins as following the character of Desmond Miles in a world where the memories of people’s ancestors can be accessed through a machine called the Atlas. Desmond finds that the corporation that is using his memories really wants use him to find ancient artifacts for power. This corporation calls themselves the Templars. Desmond’s ancestors are a part of the Assassin Brotherhood that actively fights against the Templars. This is where the story then follows Ezio Auditore. Ezio becomes an assassin when his family is murdered by a member of the Templars. Ezio then goes on a journey to stop the Templars and avenge his family. You fight alongside other members of the Creed with help from Leonardo DaVinci and his engineering prowess to stop the Templars in the Atlas and in the real world.

Project Proposal

Video games are an outlet for people of many different ages to learn a diverse amount of skills and vast information that is useful in everyday life. Video games can teach us cognitive skills, history, creativity, and sometimes about mental illness. They teach us in an interactive fashion that draws the player into a fun and immersive world without feeling like a learning experience. I will prove this point through explaining different games and their corresponding aspects of play that seek to teach players. Games like Destiny 2 or Overwatch (Teamwork), Hellblade (Psychosis and Mental Illness), Fable (Sense of morals), Assassin’s Creed (A loose base of history), Civ Rev (Strategy), Portal (Spacial Awareness, Problem Solving), Dark Souls (Motivational), and Minecraft (Creativity) can teach players many different things. Using these examples, Isabela Granic’s article “The Benefits of Playing Video Games” among other articles, and my own personal experience, I can show how video games directly teach players.

Weekly Research – Week 4

https://telltale.com/series/guardiansofthegalaxy/

Telltale is a company that produces a multitude of games with the same mechanics in common. Telltale has tackled the universe of Batman, Borderlands, The Walking Dead, Game of Thrones, and most recently Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy. In the Guardians series, the player follows the narrative surrounding Peter Quill (Star-Lord) while dipping into the past memories of the other Guardians such as Rocket Racoon and Gamora. Telltale is known for their immersive and intricate stories accompanied by their quick-time events. This puts the player directly in the first person state of mind with various universes to play within. Quick-time events are short situations, normally within a cut-scene of a game, in which the player presses a button on the controller within a small gap of time in correspondence to whatever is happening in the cut-scene. Telltale takes this up a notch by adding in dialogue options for the main character, thumb-stick movements also in correspondence with the events within the game usually associated with movement, and free-roam aspects of the story. When the entire story is centered around these mechanics, a simple story is more immersive with the player feeling like they are creating the story.

 

Weekly Research – Week 2

https://www.destinythegame.com/home

Three years after the initial release of Destiny 1, Destiny 2 is far different from it’s predecessor. A common complaint of Destiny 1 was the lack of story and the repeated play. Multiple missions consisted of the same layout over and over; find a certain object, defend it while it’s analysed, and boom – rewards. Besides solo campaign missions, there was also competitive multiplayer, co-op strikes which are longer, more difficult missions, and raids which are even longer missions with incredible bosses and painstaking puzzles. The majority of the game was based around team work and puzzle solving where some times those lines blur. In Destiny 2, the teamwork aspect has been dialed up to 11. Certain factors have been changed in the multiplayer to make cooperative fighting more prevalent and required in the game. The soon to be released raid in Destiny 2 will also amplify the need for teamwork among fire-team members for teams up to six. Teamwork is the main source of reward in the game whereas the best rewards come from the modes with the most amount of teamwork needed.

 

Weekly Rhetorical Analysis

Isabela Granic excels in her article “The Benefits of Playing Video Games” by defending common arguments against video games with research, statistics and facts. Certain platitudes such as “Video games promote laziness in children” are proven wrong by citing controlled research surrounding video games. This challenges the so-called common knowledge about video games with actual and proven facts. A factor that makes the article seem more modern and reliable is that the research that’s sited utilizes games such as Halo and Call of Duty. Both franchises have had installments in the last two years keeping the collected data fresh and up to date. As if more direct evidence was needed for the benefits of video games, Granic cites certain video games that have the primary purpose of teaching in a more entertaining manner; this concept is called “gamification”. A game called Re-Mission is a game utilized to teach child cancer patients about their illness. By citing impactful, intriguing, and emotional citations throughout the article, Granic teaches the reader in a simply understandable manner about the benefits of video games.

Granic, Isabela, et al. “The Benefits of Playing Video Games.” American Psychologist, vol. 69, no. 1, Jan. 2014, pp. 66-78. EBSCOhost. http://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&sid=2353a274-0752-41cd-84ad-72068349ea16%40sessionmgr4006

Weekly Research

Granic, Isabela, et al. “The Benefits of Playing Video Games.” American Psychologist, vol. 69, no. 1, Jan. 2014, pp. 66-78. EBSCOhost. http://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&sid=2353a274-0752-41cd-84ad-72068349ea16%40sessionmgr4006

In this article, Isabela Granic explores the benefits surrounding video games for children. She finds that through playing video games, four separate domains of child development are amplified: cognitive, motivational, emotional, and social. She also cites different video games that are directly attempting to teach children useful skills later in life, such as surgical techniques.

css.php