Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/rhetoricofgaming.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyWriting/wp-config.php on line 101
JAMES – Weekly Writing for Rhetoric of Gaming F2017

Final Project

https://docs.google.com/document/d/17NXP4ZpGpPoaI1p6TZDD-qyW7jJNOyXN8rwfH4rSEkc/edit

  1. Topic Proposal, containing a topic, a working thesis, and at least one primary (game object) and secondary source shared via the weekly blogs, no later than 1159 11/29 (5%) Yes
  2. Presentation of topic proposal, in class 11/30 (5 %) Yes
  3. Defense of topic proposal  in conference with me no later than 11/29 (5%) Yes
  4. An initial draft project in the format it will be submitted (either google docs or web page) linked from the blogs no later than 12/5 (5%) No
  5. Commenting on two other writing projects via the blogs, on or before 12/8 (5%); No
  6. A draft conference with me, on or before 12/8, show substantial progress on a drafted project (5%) Yes
  7. A near-final draft, shared/linked from a post on our shared blog, on or before 12/13 (5%); No
  8. A final round of commenting on two drafts, due on or before 12/15 (5%); Yes
  9. The quality of the finished project, due on 12/16 (55%) Yes

 

Final Annbib

Here’s my final Annbib, in case we are also supposed to put this here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1MP5L1K7VcJ0x8-uI4B61OZ6rRYuoZGJvVi_aU6EfaLU/edit

Project 2: Electric Boogaloo

For my second project, I plan on exploring race as they appear in fantasy video games, in particular examining the proclivity of Scandinavian/North European tropes inspired by Tolkien and how these effect the level of diversity that appears in games. Additionally, exploring how the marginalization of non-human species in games and comparing them to marginalization of real life peoples also serve as a potential avenue for writing. The main games I will be focusing on are The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Guild Wars, and possibly the Mass Effect series, to provide a sci-fi perspective to enhance the fantasy bits.

A source with words in it that might prove useful is  https://uta-ir.tdl.org/uta-ir/bitstream/handle/10106/25153/Simpson_uta_2502M_13243.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

Le Weekly Analysis Sauvage

This week, I will analyse in a rhetorical manner the video game Crusader Kings II. CK2 is a dynastic simulator, where the player takes control of a medieval dynasty somewhere between the years 769 and 1337. What this translates to in-game is a lot of incest, infanticide, possible genocide, human sacrifice, cannibalism, and all sorts of wholesome family activities. The game is an absolute sandbox, so the player’s goal is whatever they make it. Thus a player might make a goal like conquer all of Britain, or convert India to Norse paganism, or seduce the pope and have his babies. Every character in game is represented by a group of traits that also determine their in-game personality (for example, with a character with the ambitious trait will be more aggressive and will be much more willing to act against their liege if it gets them something). The game excels at emergent story telling, where in-game events will form a narrative that creates a coherent story in the context of that specific game. I’ve had the game form interesting stories of assassination, familial intrigue, insane rulers, unstable political situations, and much more that is nearly akin to reading a novel like Game of Thrones with more interactivity.

Weekly Research

  1. Red Orchestra 2

Red Orchestra 2: Heroes of Stalingrad. Tripwire Interactive. 2011. Video Games.

RO2 is a WWII first person shooter set during the battle of Stalingrad. The game features 64-player team matches that pit the Nazis against the Soviets. In the interest of balance and fairness, there are some limitations on what the player can do from match to match; both teams must have a similar amount of human players, so sometimes the team the player is on is forced, and the number of players allowed to use a specific weapon is limited. Most players will be restriced to bolt action rifles (Mosin Nagants or Kar-98’s, usually), while a few might end up being outfitted with sub machine guns, semi-auto rifles, or machine guns. The game also features a command structure for the players; there is a commander who is able to call in artillery strikes and direct troops, and squad leaders capable of issueing command and marking locations for artillery.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Orchestra_2:_Heroes_of_Stalingrad

 

Rhetorical Analysis

This week I’m going to talk about one of my favorite games, Verdun. The game is a WWI first person shooter with a heavy emphasis on trench warfare and (near) realism. Gameplay centers around capturing the enemy teams trenches; whichever team has advanced the most wins. Since the game centers around capturing and holding territory rather than killing as much of the enemy as possible, teamwork is absolutely essential to victory. Players won’t accomplish much if they aren’t working in coordination with their teammates; a team must cover all parts of the trench in order to successfully defend it, must outnumber the enemy in their trench to take it, must coordinate gas and artillery strikes to where it would be most effective for the team.

 

Other than the game objective, the main element of the game that encourages teamwork is the squad-based organization of teams. When the player joins the game, they are put into a four-person squad that represents a specific military unit. Each squad has four different roles that are meant to fill specific functions. For example, the U.S. Army unit, the “Doughboys” (as they were called in the war), consists of an NCO, a sniper, a machine gunner, and a grenadier. Each is meant to accomplish something that the others can’t (the NCO calls in artillery while the machine gunner provides cover fire, or the sniper picks off enemy machine guns while the grenadier lobs grenades around corners to clear out enemies). While a player could try to go it alone, working with the other members of their squad is their best bet for overall victory.

Weekly Research

Vampire: The Masquerade- Bloodlines. Troika Games. 2004. Video Games

VTMB is a narrative-driven RPG in which the player takes control of a newly created vampire and must learn how to successfully navigate byzantine vampire politics as well as their own inner nature in order to survive.. The game presents a great deal of choices in how to resolve quests, often posing moral choices. In many instances (though not all), combat is avoidable, and many missions penalize the player should they kill anyone. The game also does much with immersing the player in the gameplay; the player needs to drink blood in order to fuel various vampiric abilities, and the world is extremely detailed.

http://vtmb.wikia.com/wiki/Vampire:_The_Masquerade_%E2%80%93_Bloodlines_Wiki

Project 1 Draft Write-Up

The three games I plan on examining are The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines, and Fallout 3. I plan to explore immersion using a game’s playing on a player’s sense of morality (using Vampire and Fallout), the engagement of the player with the story (using Vampire), and with the player’s engagement with the world-space (using Vampire and Skyrim). The main aspect’s I’ll be looking at with each of these topics is believability (https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/4e2b/c7e3730273f8ef669aaea57a0e590a1957d7.pdf#page=96 deals with all three games I’ve listed) and level of player interaction (ie, how much control does the player have over their own actions? How much does their actions affect the world? Is the player given a solid reason to care about the world?). I’m planning on creating a webspace on wordpress and using gameplay videos (either of my own making or else taken from the internet) to augment and expand upon my points. I also should be able to provide plenty of screenshots of my own.

Thesis: Through an immersive play-space driven by story, world, and sense of morality, video games can engage the player to the point where they mentally transfer consciousness from the real world tot heir character in the game space, creating an escape from the present reality to another one.

Weekly Research

  1. Majewski, J. A. K. U. B. “Cultural heritage in role-playing video games: a map of approaches.” Furnace Journal (2015).

Majewski’s article deals with video games’ evocation of cultural heritage in their settings. Through the utilization of certain cultural influences (like Scandinavian influences in Skyrim), games can draw in an audience that that particular heritage appeals to. Majewski attempts to categorize the different ways games use cultural heritage, and focuses primarily on RPGs.  

https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/39112491/Majewski_2015a_-_Cultural_Heritage_in_Role-Playing_Video_Games._A_Map_of_Approaches.pdf?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1506918307&Signature=uIoURiwoQiZjcUdC7MPWzuYeJuM%3D&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DCultural_Heritage_in_Role-Playing_Video.pdf

Project 1 Proposal

For the first project, I plan to use the “Play and the Player” prompt to explore the player’s relationship to both their character and to the game world in assorted RPG’s. In particular, I wish to examine how through the creation of an immersive game-world and play system a game temporarily creates a new identity for the player that subsumes the player’s real world identity for the duration of play. The game’s through which I plan on exploring this are open-world rpg’s like Skyrim and the Fallout series, and more narrow rpgs like Dragon Age. A quick search uncovered a wealth of information on Skyrim, with articles like “Unbroken Immersion: The Skyrim Experience” (Simkins, David, Seann Dikkers, and Elizabeth Owen. “Unbroken Immersion: The Skyrim Experience.” Well Played–Vol. 2, No.: 13.) being ubiquitous.

James Smith Weekly Research

 

  • Victoria II. Paradox Interactive. 2010. Video Game.

 

Victoria II is a grand-strategy game created by Paradox interactive. In the game, the player takes control of a country in the year 1836 and then leads that country until the game’s end date in 1936. Every country that existed or could have existed in that time frame, from major nations like the United Kingdom to small nations like Ulm, is both portrayed and playable. The game’s main draw is the complex political and economic system; different political parties (liberals, conservatives, communists, fascists, etc.) can come into power, and the party in power determines what the player can do (liberals will force lower taxes and more laissez faire style economy, conservatives do the opposite, etc.). Likewise, the nation’s economy will grow and develop with or without the player’s intervention, and is affected by what kind of factories are built, how many workers are available, tax rates, and numerous other factors. Like all Paradox games, Victoria II is highly moddable and has a very large modding community that surrounds it.

http://www.victoria2wiki.com/Victoria_2_Wiki

Weekly Research 9/17/2017

 

  • Dragon Age: Origins. Bioware. November 3, 2009. Video Game.

 

Dragon Age: Origins is the first game in Bioware’s critically acclaimed Dragon Age series. It is a tactical RPG that concerns itself heavily with the player’s choices in order to shape the overall narrative. It follows the story of a player character who is drafted into a legendary order known as the Grey Wardens in order to a race of abominations called Darkspawn. What the player does (as in, who they side with, who lives and who dies, etc.) not only matters during the course of the game, it also carries over into future installments in the series, as the player is able to import a save file into the other games and see how their choices affected the overall world. The game is also known for its memorable companions who react and modify their opinion of the player character based on their decisions. Features like these are essential to both Bioware’s Dragon Age and Mass Effect series, creating a high level of player involvement and conscientiousness in their desicions during play.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_Age:_Origins

Rhetorical Analysis 2: Electric Boogaloo

In the second half of the first chapter of Homo Ludens, Huzinga spends a lot of time comparing the act of play with that of a sacred rite or ritual. The reason for this is to point out that both have specific, predefined sets of rules and practices that take place inside of a designated world space (church, playing field, etc.). He also makes the point that those who violate this world-space (for example, by breaking the rules) are often shunned or looked down upon.

From a rhetorical standpoint, this comparison lends some credibility to the idea that play is something that should be taken and studied seriously. By comparing it to something that is already taken in such a manner, the kind of association gained from such reasoning creates the idea that the act of play is a deeper and integral part of human culture, one that fundamentally cannot be divorced from human existence.

Weekly Analysis 1

Tania Smith’s definition of rhetoric basically claims that it is human communication used in a strategic manner in order to persuade or inspire another human (although there could probably be an argument that rhetoric can also be used on the self, though I digress). She claims that rhetoric is used by everyone, even though some people try to give it a negative connotation. This was of particular interest to me, since it implies that most people conflate rhetoric with propaganda (which, in itself, is rhetoric). Smith additionally points out that act of defaming rhetoric would additionally be an example of the usage of rhetoric, since it’s an attempt to deliberately influence the ideals of others.

Smith tries to make the assertion that rhetoric is best used for good purposes. While that is a noble goal, I believe that rhetoric is neutral, without begin inherently good or evil. Smith attempting to convince the reader that rhetoric ought to be used for good purposes is in itself an interesting usage of rhetoric in a piece about rhetoric.

css.php